Skip to content

The 1919 Boston police strike sought a union, and the department replaced nearly three-quarters of the force

The department's own history says the strike changed the BPD. Governor Coolidge refused to put the men who left back on duty.

Michelle McCormack

Michelle McCormack

Michelle is the founder of Secret Boston and a Producer. Born and raised on the mean streets of JP, she was once chased by a lion in Africa while on assignment for Town & Country Magazine.

Faneuil Hall and the Custom House Tower in downtown Boston

After the Boston police strike of 1919, the Boston Police Department eliminated nearly three-quarters of its force and filled the ranks with returning soldiers from World War I. That is the department's own account of how the strike changed the BPD. The same official history dates the department itself to 1854, when the city replaced earlier Watch organizations with a force of 250 officers. Each was paid $2 a shift, walked a beat, and was forbidden to hold outside employment.

The strike itself, in September 1919, sought better wages and working conditions for patrolmen, and recognition for their trade union. The department says the effort made national headlines.

By the official BPD history, the department had already grown into a large city force. At the turn of the 20th century it had 1,000 patrolmen, and its work had widened to include motor vehicle traffic after the department bought its first patrol car in 1903 and its first patrol wagon in 1912. The official history says Boston was the first U.S. city to use an automobile as a police cruiser. That first car went into service at Station 16 in July 1903 and covered about 60 miles a day in the Back Bay. A chauffeur drove it, and a uniformed officer sat on a seat high enough "to allow him to look over the back fences." The 1919 strike, in the department's telling, is the event that then cut that force down and rebuilt it.

What the governor said at the time

On September 24, 1919, Governor Calvin Coolidge issued a proclamation from Boston. He said a large body of policemen, urging others to join them, had deserted their posts "in the deliberate intention to intimidate and coerce the Government of this Commonwealth." He called the act voluntary, "against the advice of their well wishers, long discussed and premeditated." By doing so, he said, they had, through the law, "dispossessed themselves" and gone out of office. "They stand as though they had never been appointed." Other police, he said, had remained on duty, and he called them "the real heroes of this crisis."

Coolidge also praised the State Guard, which he said had "responded most efficiently," and the thousands who had volunteered for the Guard and the Militia. He said money had been contributed "from every walk of life by the hundreds of thousands" for those who stayed on duty.

He refused to put public security back in the hands of the men who had left. "To place the maintenance of the public security in the hands of a body of men who have attempted to destroy it would be to flout the sovereignty of the laws the people have made," he wrote. "The authority of the Commonwealth cannot be intimidated or coerced. It cannot be compromised." He added, "There is no middle ground. Every attempt to prevent the formation of a new police force is a blow at the Government." He also wrote, "No man has a right to place his own ease or convenience or the opportunity of making money above his duty to the State."

Where the strike sits in 1919

A Massachusetts official history of the period lists the Boston Police Strike in September 1919 among the labor strikes that fed public fear during the Red Scare of 1919 and 1920, alongside rising unemployment after World War I and a wave of union activity. That is the state's framing of the moment, not a full tally of every cause of the walkout.

The official BPD history is similarly blunt about the aftermath: nearly three-quarters of the force was eliminated, and the department hired returning World War I soldiers to fill those jobs. Coolidge's proclamation had already drawn that line. The men who left, in his telling, would not be the men who came back.

The proclamation also asked citizens to support the government's authority. "This is the cause of all the people," Coolidge wrote. "I call on every citizen to stand by me in executing the oath of my office by supporting the authority of the Government and resisting all assaults upon it."

For more of the city's past in plain terms, we have a short history of how Boston got its name and a guide to 10 Boston neighborhoods.

← Back to Secret Boston

Save to list

Create a free account to save places, events, articles, and guides.

Create accountSign in